When tradition was too hard to face, I embraced a new culture.
Last year was the hardest Thanksgiving of my life. I was too fragile to be alone, yet too broken to join a holiday table. My world had just collapsed, and I could barely eat, let alone celebrate. My sister and cousin—two of the most wonderful humans in the world—didn’t leave my side. They each canceled their own plans with their families and significant others, choosing instead to sit with me during one of the darkest weeks of my life.
I can’t recall who suggested it, but one of them said we should do something completely different that year—no turkey, no stuffing, no reminders of what I’d lost. “Let’s go out for Greek,” they said, and that’s exactly what we did.
The idea felt strange at first, but I agreed because I couldn’t bear anything that resembled the life I once knew. The thought of other families gathered around their tables, laughing, sharing, celebrating—it was too much. My husband had already moved on with someone else long before he officially left. That week, he was with her. I knew it. And that truth lived like a weight in my chest I couldn’t breathe through.
When we arrived at the bustling Greek restaurant in upstate New York, we were welcomed joyfully to sit amongst the many others who, for whatever reasons of their own, were also not celebrating Thanksgiving in the traditional manner. There was something comforting about knowing I wasn’t the only one who needed a reason to be there and not somewhere else that evening. It smelled of lemon, garlic, and roasted tomatoes—warm, but not familiar.
I sat there, quiet, unable to pretend I was having fun, but for the first time in days, I decided to try a real meal. I ordered shrimp baked with tomatoes and feta. The dish was rich with olive oil, garlic, and herbs—finished with briny melted feta that finished the dish. It was simple, but soulful. And it was as far away from a traditional Thanksgiving dinner as I could get. It was in that Greek restaurant, surrounded by two people who refused to let me face the world alone, I began to realize how different my life was about to become. It was both a humbling and overwhelming realization.
Stay in the Loop.
Real food. Real stories. Sent with love—right to your inbox.
That meal was the first thing that stayed down in days—and it would become one of the last full meals I ate for a long time to come. Dark days were ahead for me, and my relationship with food would reflect that.
As I reflect on the anniversary of that time in my life, I wanted to honor it by recreating the meal that marked the end of Thanksgiving as I once knew it—and the beginning of something unknown. It reminds me that comfort doesn’t always come from what’s familiar. Sometimes it’s found in the unexpected—new flavors, new traditions, new beginnings.