Modern Comfort Food Cookbook Review

By Christina Collins

Anyone who knows me knows without questions that I am an Ina Garten fan. Correction- I am a mega fan. Not a day goes by that Ina isn’t on my mind. I ask myself constantly, “WWID?” She is my culinary soul mate. She just doesn’t know it it.

Barefoot contessa cookbooks

I own every single one of the Barefoot Contessa cookbooks and they are my prized possessions. I never get tired of flipping through them. Ever.

The reason why I am so loyal to Ina and her cookbooks is because they are reliable. Period. I have made countless recipes of hers. No, seriously, I mean actually countless. I tried to count and lost track. There are maybe one or two that didn’t come out as good as I had expected. But zero have actually disappointed me. Additionally, Ina’s cookbooks feature incredible pictures that don’t just inspire me, but they are real. When I follow her recipe it actually comes out looking just like the picture. See below are decide for yourself:

Ina Garten’s Modern Comfort Food Recipe pictures compared to mine.

So when her latest cookbook, Modern Comfort Food, was released in October 2020, I was one of the first to order it.

When it first arrived I was excited as ever! I couldn’t wait to sit down with a glass of wine and my stack of post-its, and go slowly, page by page, reading each recipe, the notes, and get inspired by the pictures.

I’ll be honest. My first time looking it over, I wasn’t so impressed! Looking back I’m not sure why. I thought I wouldn’t want to make too many of the featured recipes in Modern Comfort Food. Well, I was wrong because guess what happened next? I started cooking. And I couldn’t stop. And dare I say it, but it may be her best cookbook yet. It is a fantastic cookbook and I am obsessed.

It started with the sausage & peppers. Which I have now made twice in two weeks. Then onto the Cauliflower with lemon and capers which is now my absolute favorite way to make cauliflower. Then, although I have made both before, a re-visit & rekindled love for Ina’s homemade caesar dressing & green salad vinaigrette.

sausage & peppers
Get the recipe for Roasted Sausage & Peppers

Next came smashed eggs over toast, and the creme de le creme… the creamed spinach with baked eggs.

soft boiled eggs on toast

It didn’t stop there. I made the Baked Cod with garlic & ritz crumbs, ultimate tuna melts and creamy tomato soup.

The creamy tomato soup is incredible!

I kept cooking. I made the grilled oysters with lemon dill butter (I roasted them- Shhhh! Don’t tell Ina.) I made the fig & cheese toasts and the potato galettes with smoked salmon.

Every single recipe has impressed me. I don’t know how she does it. Ina Garten has a impeccable palate, a way of making seemingly difficult recipes approachable, and her recipes can be counted on.

Ina garten cookbooks
Modern Comfort Food is the newest released cookbook by Ina Garten

In each of Ina’s cookbooks she offers tips, stories and recommended products. In Modern Comfort Food she included some of her favorite staple ingredients. And contrary to what some may think about her cooking being “too fancy”, the ingredients are actually quite basic and include things like DeCecco pasta, Goya chipotle peppers in Adobo sauce, and Hellman’s Mayo. She has done her homework, so it’s best just to trust her recommendations and buy what Ina does. I do!

I highly recommend this cookbook if you are looking for new inspiration, new skills and recipes you can really rely on. I have no doubt that within the next two months I will have made just about every recipe featured in the Modern Comfort Food Cookbook. I confidently give it 5 stars!

I’m off to the kitchen… Ina’s Penne Vodka is on the menu! (Recipe from the Foolproof Cookbook.)

Share socially… 

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest

Leave a Comment

More to explore


The Gold Medal Dining Experience

I had the opportunity to enjoy a 6 course meal in an intimate setting prepared by the royalty of the culinary world, namely Chefs Tom Colicchio, Daniel Boulud, Daniel Humm, David Bouley and Florian Bellanger. This was a once in a lifetime culinary experience.

Read More
Oyster Rockefeller

Oysters Rockefeller

These decedent roasted oysters are served right out of the shell and will make you feel as “Rich as Rockefeller” while eating them!

Read More

How to get the most out of your Basil plant

Basil grown from seed will always be strongest and it is really easy. Once established,  clip it right above the first set of four leaves and continue to do so every time you clip it and it will reward you with large and bountiful healthy leaves all season long.

Read More